Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Preconfigured solutions

Downloading a pre-installed VM versus building your own.

I liked the experience of doing both. In our last project, downloading a self-contained VM with Omeka, I found the procedure fairly easy to do. The problem I ran into was in the transfer process of getting my collection from my host machine into the VM but I found a round-about way to get this done. Certainly, preconfigured solutions provide more time to concentrate on working on getting the collection in order. From a learning standpoint though, one would not want to skip the experience of installing a VM from scratch. Although the process is actually fairly easy to do, you go through the installation step by step and are able to control what gets installed. This gives you an opportunity to see in your mind how each building block is built, one on top of the other, to create the whole machine in the end. If I had not been through the experience of doing a basic install of a VM before (I must have done this 3-4 times already; maybe more because of mistakes) I think I definitely would have lost out on learning how a repository is structured and modified. At this point, I still don't think I feel comfortable running through the basic install without following Bruce's tutorial on YouTube. I did it once without following it and certain screens came up that I was uncertain of as what to do. Like anything, if I ran through it every day, I wouldn't feel the need to depend on Bruce.

My preference for one or the other? I like both. I like the feeling of succeeding after the full install. And I like the immediacy of viewing success with Omeka pre-installed on the VM. They both kept me on my toes.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Service providers and repositories

Here, I have reviewed three service providers from the Open Archives list of registered providers and examined their search functions.

GEO-LEO--GEO Library Experts Online

This virtual library GEO-LEO (www.geo-leo.org) is funded by the German Research Foundation and offers searching and browsing in about 6 million earth sciences and mining related bibliograhphic records.

Some collections from the communities here:

Fach-Publikationen aus dem deutschprachigen Raum [17]
geoberg.de - Publikationen [18]
GEO-LEO Materials [7]
Institutional Journals, Series and Conferences [127]
Publikationen der Technischen Universität Bergakademie Freiberg [4]
Publikationen der Universität Göttingen [5]
University Press [7]

NORA—Norwegian Open Research Archives

Selected topics:

Student theses, conference papers, books, newspaper articles, journal articles

Languages: German, Norwegian, English, Swedish, Danish, Spanish

Harvests from European institutes and colleges and universities. Here is a short listing:

Norwegian Defence Research Establishment
Michelsen Institute
Norwegian School of Economics and Business Administration (BORA)
Directorate of Integration and Diversity
National Centre for Violence and Traumatic Stress
University in Oslo (DUO)
University College
Norwegian University of Science and Technology
University in Tromsø (Munin)
University College
University College
Telemark University College
Helsebiblioteket's Research Archive
University in Bergen (BORA)
Geological Survey of Norway (NGU)
Norwegian University of Life Sciences

METALIS— METAresearch in Library and Information Science

METALIS harvests metadata from institutions that offer full-text papers and documents about Library and Information Science

METALIS harvests from these Data Providers:

Archive Ouverte en Sciences de l'Information et de la Communication.
ArXiv.
Caltech Library System Papers and Publications.
CNR Bologna Research Library.
Digital Library of Information Science and Technology.
E-Prints in Library and Information Science.
Librarians' Digital Library.
Mémoires de 3 cycle en Sciences de l'Information et de la Communication.
Thèse-EN-ligne.

What makes a good federated collection? From a researcher’s point of view, the collection has to be broad and inclusive of material not only from your own geographic area but worldwide. Materials should be translatable into your native language. This material should be recent, considering recent to be within the last three years. In some scientific communities, material may still be worthy and useful if much older than that, especially in comparison studies and those in the medical and health fields. All three service providers appear to be fairly good federated collections in the sense that for their regions, they are providing a decent amount of usable materials to their communities. There are positives and negatives when a service provider is very large. Unless that provider has an extremely good searching system, you can get bogged down in looking through an enormous amount of records, trying to find one item. You have a great deal more information so there may be more choice. On the one hand, I prefer more rather than less. In this case, at least I know I’ll find something when I need it. On the other hand, I may not want to spend hours or days trying to locate what I need. I think this may be more an individual choice, more personal preference, than anything else.